Paper Mate Handwriting Mechanical Pencils, 5 count

Thick 1.3 mm lead in a chunky barrel for early writers who press hard.

Five Paper Mate Handwriting mechanical pencils with thick 1.3 mm #2 lead, plus two eraser refills and 12 lead refills, as listed in the title. The thicker lead is less likely to snap than standard mechanical lead. They are mechanical pencils, not the wooden primary or jumbo pencils many early-grade lists name, so check your list before buying.

$8.25$9.40Save 12%Price as of Nov 18, 2026, 1:10 PM ET
Stash It
Buy at Amazon

Retailer links may earn ChalkStash a commission.

76ChalkStash scoreOur own 0 to 100 rating, not a customer review. See how it is worked out.
QualityCombined rating across stores, weighted by how many people rated it
77
DemandHow often school supply lists ask for this kind of item
98
ValuePrice per unit against other picks for the same need
50
AvailabilityIn stock with a recent price check, at one or more stores
80
Editor notesReviewed and written up by ChalkStash
50

Why it belongs in a classroom

Early-grade lists often ask for fat or primary pencils that are easier for small hands to grip. Reviewers say these suit children and adults alike, find the thick lead comfortable and durable, and like the smooth, soft writing and sturdy erasers. No common complaint stands out.

What buyers say

4.8 out of 5 on Amazon from 628 ratings, as of Oct 4, 2026. Summarized by ChalkStash.

Reviewers praise the writing quality, the comfortable thick lead and the durability, and say the pencils suit both children and adults. No common complaint stands out.

Liked

  • Thick lead resists breaking
  • Comfortable to hold
  • Smooth writing
  • Sturdy erasers

Teacher reviews

No ChalkStash member reviews yet. Used it with a class? Your notes help the next teacher choose.

Size and details

4.88 in7.88 innew pencil

0.51 in × 4.88 in × 7.88 in

Longest side 7.88 in, about the same length as a new pencil.

Weighs 0 oz.

In the pack
5 pencils, about $1.65 each at the last price check
Lead Size
1.3 mm
Lead Grade
#2
Lead Refills
12
Eraser Refills
2
Color
Red
Material Type
Plastic
Age Range Description
Kid
Recommended Uses For Product
Writing, Coloring

Listing details come from the retailer and may change.

Who it's for

Grades
Pre-K to Grade 2
On classroom supply lists Asked for most in Kindergarten.

Recommended grades

A few more good finds